Captain America: Brave New World – Film Review

Cast: Anthony Mackie, Danny Ramirez, Shira Haas, Carl Lumbly, Xosha Roquemore, Giancarlo Esposito, Tim Blake Nelson, Harrison Ford, Liv Tyler

Director: Julius Onah

Synopsis: After an attempt is made on the life of the President of the United States Thaddeus Ross (Ford), Captain America must investigate a conspiracy which threatens to have major international ramifications…

Review: It has been quite the journey for Sam Wilson in the Marvel Cinematic Universe since we were first introduced to him as Steve Rogers’ jogging buddy in Captain America: The Winter Soldier. Since then, he helped to confront and Steve the nefarious HYRDA, took his friend’s side as the Avengers went to war with themselves, fought in the war against a mad Titan with the fate of the entire universe at stake. It all culminated in the passing of the torch shield to becoming his friend’s successor as Captain America. A mantle he momentarily relinquished before reclaiming what was rightfully his. Now in the wake of the events of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, Sam Wilson is ready to take flight for his first mission, in a film which sadly fails to soar and reach the lofty heights of its predecessors.

It has been a few years since Sam fought with Bucky Barnes to take down the Flag Smashers, and in that time, Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross has been elected as President of the United States. Despite having had their differences in the past, the new man in the Oval Office tasks Cap and the new Falcon Joaquin Torres (Ramirez) to foil an illegal arms deal in the first step of a more collaborative relationship. Ross later informs Sam he wants his help to rebuild the Avengers. During a summit at the White House concerning the emergence of Celestial Island and a rare new material, an attempt is made on the President’s life by veteran super soldier Isiah Bradley (Lumbly). With the US on the brink of a major global conflict, Sam must find out who was behind the attempted assassination of the President and uncover the truth behind this global conspiracy and clear Bradley’s name.

It is no exaggeration to say that in 2025, the world is a fraught and sometimes scary place, with entrenched and bitter political divides showing no signs of easing. In such times, making a tense spy-political thriller is a brave and dangerous move as the film has to navigate such a fraught political metaphorical minefield. However, it is not entirely without precedent, as the Russo brothers and screenwriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely successfully tackled similar themes with spectacular success The Winter Soldier and its sequel Civil War. Whether or not you feel the MCU has lost its way since the high of Avengers: Endgame is beside the point, as it was always going to be a tall order for Brave New World to follow in the footsteps of its predecessors.

“You may be Captain America, but you’re not Steve Rogers”, the President scornfully tells Sam after the foiled assassination attempt. “You’re right, I’m not”, Sam sharply retorts. It is a highlight in a film which doesn’t offer many, but also a statement of intent for the new star-spangled man with the shield that he will forge his own legacy as the iconic superhero. In his seventh big screen appearance in this role. Mackie is once again superb. He is fully aware that the legacy of the title he now has comes with an enormous responsibility, at one point grappling with the dilemma as to whether he should have taken the super soldier serum, but this is what makes him more than worthy of that shield. When you have gone up against what he has armed with just a wingsuit, what does he have to fear, especially since now he has the welcome addition of a vibranium shield, and the new Falcon by his side. Although, despite being one of the more interesting parts of the miniseries, Isiah Bradley is once again frustratingly forced to sit in a jail cell, when he really deserves a chance to show what he can do.

The irony is that this script, written by Onah and four other credited writers, could have benefited from some script serum to enhance it and give it some additional polish. One can only speculate, but given certain events that occurred in 2024, it seems that the political themes of the film may have been diluted due to the current state of world politics. In addition to continuing the story established in the preceding miniseries, the film serves as a sequel to both Eternals (good to see this underappreciated film get acknowledged) and The Incredible Hulk, as the villain is a character that audiences may have nearly forgotten. Portraying a role that was successfully played by someone for many years is never an easy task, but Ford does an excellent job as Ross, succeeding the late William Hurt. Along with his signature gruffness, Ross is grappling with the daunting challenge of leading a country on the brink of major conflict while also battling his own internal struggles and trying to reconnect with his daughter, Betty (Tyler). Given the current state of US presidents, especially now, you’d take Ross’s leadership any day of the week.

Despite Ford’s impressive portrayal of Ross and his complex (and possibly red) inner demons, the film’s action, while undeniably slick and well-crafted, fails to bring anything new or memorable to the MCU. It frustratingly adheres to a formulaic structure, which feels like a significant missed opportunity for what could have been a gripping political thriller, similar to its predecessors. The 35th entry into the MCU could have marked a bold new direction for both the star-spangled hero and the wider universe. Instead, it feels tired and stale, as if our titular hero’s wings have been clipped, leaving him unable to rise above this uninspiring and frankly bland story.

Despite stellar performances from Mackie and Ford, with the former more than proving himself worthy of the shield, Brave New World is a political thriller that seems too afraid to go for the jugular in these politically fraught times, while also lacking in thrills.

© A24. Universal Pictures and Focus Features

The Brutalist – Film Review

Cast: Adrien Brody, Felicity Jones, Guy Pearce, Joe Alwyn, Raffey Cassidy, Stacy Martin, Emma Laird, Isaach de Bankolé, Alessandro Nivola

Director: Brady Corbet

Synopsis: A talented architect escapes post-World War II Europe and emigrates to the US to start a new life in pursuit of the American dream…

Review: An arduous boat journey, followed by a walk down a gangway, to mark the start of a new life in a country that offers so much potential and opportunities for success. This is the core principle of the American Dream, a concept popularized by US writer James Truslow Adams during the Great Depression. It has been ingrained in the ideals of the nation for decades. No matter who you are or where you come from, you can achieve your dreams in the United States of America. This promise has inspired millions of immigrants to move to the country and lies at the heart of this ambitious and powerful film by Brady Corbet.

In post-World War II Europe, Hungarian-Jewish architect László Toth (Brody) emigrates to the United States after surviving the Holocaust. Unfortunately, he has been separated from his wife, Erzsébet (Jones), who remains in Europe with their niece, Zsófia (Cassidy). After disembarking from the boat and catching an upside-down glimpse of Lady Liberty in all her glory, László makes his way to Pennsylvania to stay with his cousin, Attila (Nivola), and Attila’s wife, Audrey (Laird). Attila offers László the chance to work in his furniture business. One fateful day, they receive an offer from Harry Lee Van Buren (Alwyn), who wants to hire them for a job to renovate the library at his father Harrison’s (Pearce) home. Initially, Harrison, a wealthy industrialist, strongly disapproves of the renovations and dismisses László from his home without paying him for the work. However, after László’s designs for the library receive glowing praise from the architectural community, Harrison returns to offer László the opportunity to design his magnum opus: a community centre that will house a gymnasium, chapel, and reading room in honour of Harrison’s late mother.

In such times when the subject of immigration is at the centre of hateful and bigoted rhetoric emanating from certain world leaders, the arrival of such an expansive and grand film in terms of its scope and themes couldn’t be more timely. Like a vast and tall structure built to last for generations to come, Corbet and Mona Fastvold’s weighty screenplay tackles a plethora of meaningful and potent subjects including the Jewish identity, the unremitting horrors the Holocaust inflicted on the Jewish people, the joys and hardships that go along with looking to fulfil the promise of the American dream as an immigrant, and the desire to make or construct something which will ensure you leave a lasting legacy on the world. Yet that ambition comes with a cost, because as Laszlo finds out, to what extent will you drive yourself into the ground in pursuit of perfection when the path to get there is littered with seemingly mountainous obstacles too heavy to move?

To leave everything you have known behind to pursue a brand new life on an entirely new continent is a journey that millions have embarked upon across generations. For Adrien Brody, whose mother and grandparents fled their native Hungary to emigrate to the US, it is evident how much of a personal role it is for him. He channels this into his incredible performance as we can see Laszlo is a man driven by his passion for his craft, and his determination to make a better life for himself so that one day Erzsébet and Zsofia will finally be able to join him in the US. Such is the lengthy process, it takes a while for Erzsébet and Zsofia to finally be reunited, but when she does finally arrive in the US, Jones more than makes her presence known with a powerful performance. As the wealthy benefactor who plays a central role in giving Laszlo a chance to realise his vision, Pearce is utterly compelling as Van Buren Sr. There is a warmth to him, a generosity where he recognises Laszlo’s talents. However, beneath that warm and embracing exterior, there is a hint of a darker side, a jealousy and bitterness that threatens to come to the surface as the film, and this hugely ambitious project progresses.

Whenever a film clocks in at a runtime exceeding three hours, discussions inevitably arise as to whether it justifies such a lengthy runtime. With a built-in intermission, the film’s structure keeps eyes firmly transfixed on the screen, be it the awe-inspiring production design, Lol Crawley’s breathtaking cinematography and the majestic score by Daniel Blumberg. Given the exorbitant budgets with which many films are made these days, how the film only cost $10m is astonishing and should serve as a lesson for filmmakers that exorbitant budgets aren’t always needed. However, even with the lengthy runtime, during which the audience has been taken on an immersive journey across several decades, the conclusion comes off as very abrupt and rushed. Like spending years on an exciting construction project, only to haphazardly complete the final stages in a comparatively short period. Even with such a lengthy runtime, the film would have benefitted from an extra 15 to 20 minutes to provide audiences with some necessary closure.

Despite some question marks about the film’s use of AI to enhance the Hungarian dialogue of László and Erzsébet, as well as for some of the former’s drawings, what Corbet has brought to the screen with only his third feature film is mightily impressive. With its pertinent exploration of the struggles of immigrants to fulfil the promise that the American dream sold to them, combined with its weighty themes of striving to establish yourself as a master in your craft, only to be held back due to a plethora of societal factors, including but not limited to the brutal (pun absolutely intended) nature of capitalist society. The wondrous filmmaking will only carry increased significance as time goes by.